Realist: news and analytics

Русский/English/العربية

  • News
  • Russia
  • Caucasus
  • Opinion
  • Interviews
  • Experts
No Result
View All Result
Realist: news and analytics
  • News
  • Russia
  • Caucasus
  • Opinion
  • Interviews
  • Experts
No Result
View All Result
Realist: news and analytics

New Delhi will not side with Washington against Beijing

India's significant weaknesses in comparison with China and her inevitable proximity to China guarantee that New Delhi will never be drawn into any confrontation between the United States and China, which does not directly threaten its own security, says Carnegie Endowment analyst Ashley J. Tellis.

   
May 7, 2023, 06:05
World
Image: Craig Stephens

Image: Craig Stephens

WASHINGTON (Realist English). For the past two decades, Washington has made an enormous bet in the Indo-Pacific—that treating India as a key partner will help the United States in its geopolitical rivalry with China. From George W. Bush onward, successive U.S. presidents have bolstered India’s capabilities on the assumption that doing so automatically strengthens the forces that favor freedom in Asia, Ashley J. Tellis, Senior Fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace notes in a column for Foreign Affairs magazine.

“Washington’s current expectations of India are misplaced. India’s significant weaknesses compared with China, and its inescapable proximity to it, guarantee that New Delhi will never involve itself in any U.S. confrontation with Beijing that does not directly threaten its own security.India values cooperation with Washington for the tangible benefits it brings but does not believe that it must, in turn, materially support the United States in any crisis—even one involving a common threat such as China.” the expert notes.

In his opinion, the fundamental problem is that the United States and India have divergent ambitions for their security partnership.:

“As it has done with allies across the globe, Washington has sought to strengthen India’s standing within the liberal international order and, when necessary, solicit its contributions toward coalition defense. Yet New Delhi sees things differently. It does not harbor any innate allegiance toward preserving the liberal international order and retains an enduring aversion toward participating in mutual defense. 

It seeks to acquire advanced technologies from the United States to bolster its own economic and military capabilities and thus facilitate its rise as a great power capable of balancing China independently, but it does not presume that American assistance imposes any further obligations on itself.”

The Carnegie Endowment expert believes that as the Joe Biden administration continues to expand its investments in India, it should base its policy “on a realistic assessment of Indian strategy and not on any delusions of New Delhi becoming a comrade-in-arms during some future crisis with Beijing.”

AsiaChinaIndiaIndia’s Foreign PolicyUnited StatesUS Foreign PolicyUS-India Relations
Previous Post

An unknown Indian company supplies millions of barrels of Russian oil

Next Post

Arkady Karapetyan: The Armenian ideology should be based on faith

Related Posts

Trump’s 30% tariffs ignite EU backlash and threaten trade war escalation
World

China deepens strategic ties with Egypt amid Middle East tensions and global realignments

13 July, 2025
Trump’s 30% tariffs ignite EU backlash and threaten trade war escalation
World

Erdoğan hails ‘new page in history’ as Kurdish militants begin disarmament

13 July, 2025
Israel: Iran’s enriched uranium may still be retrievable after U.S. airstrikes
World

Israel: Iran’s enriched uranium may still be retrievable after U.S. airstrikes

11 July, 2025
Thaksin Shinawatra’s fall marks the twilight of an era in Thai politics
World

Thaksin Shinawatra’s fall marks the twilight of an era in Thai politics

10 July, 2025
Nvidia briefly hits $4tn market cap, leading AI-driven tech rally
World

Former South Korean president Yoon Suk Yeol arrested over failed martial law attempt

10 July, 2025
Macron urges UK and France to rebuild ties: ‘Let’s not allow the Channel to grow wider’
World

Macron urges UK and France to rebuild ties: ‘Let’s not allow the Channel to grow wider’

9 July, 2025
Most Popular
Most Popular
Gen X poised for major inheritance boom amid record baby boomer wealth transfers

Gen X poised for major inheritance boom amid record baby boomer wealth transfers

13 July, 2025

WASHINGTON (Realist English). Members of Generation X — those currently aged 45 to 60 — are expected to benefit from...

Trump’s 30% tariffs ignite EU backlash and threaten trade war escalation

Erdoğan hails ‘new page in history’ as Kurdish militants begin disarmament

13 July, 2025

ANKARA (Realist English). Turkey’s President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan declared the beginning of a new era as militants from the outlawed...

FBI launches criminal investigation into former CIA and FBI chiefs over 2016 Russia probe

FBI launches criminal investigation into former CIA and FBI chiefs over 2016 Russia probe

9 July, 2025

WASHINGTON (Realist English). The Federal Bureau of Investigation has opened criminal investigations into former CIA Director John Brennan and former...

Roman Starovoit

Roman Starovoit and the collapse of a technocratic glossy dream

8 July, 2025

MOSCOW (Realist English). I can’t stop thinking about the story of Roman Starovoit. If you think about it, the former...

Opinion

Roman Starovoit

Roman Starovoit and the collapse of a technocratic glossy dream

8 July, 2025

MOSCOW (Realist English). I can’t stop thinking about the story of Roman Starovoit. If you think about it, the former...

Bezos’s Venetian wedding: a manifesto of new feudalism

Bezos’s Venetian wedding: a manifesto of new feudalism

30 June, 2025

VENICE (Realist English). When Jeff Bezos rents half of Venice for a $50 million wedding, it is more than the...

Not Mossad’s strength — but Iran’s weakness

Not Mossad’s strength — but Iran’s weakness

16 June, 2025

TBILISI (Realist English). The recent targeted assassinations of senior IRGC commanders and high-ranking Iranian officers are not simply the triumph...

The Church belongs to Christ, not to politicians: The Armenian Apostolic Church becomes a casualty of Yerevan’s political agony

The Church belongs to Christ, not to politicians: The Armenian Apostolic Church becomes a casualty of Yerevan’s political agony

12 June, 2025

YEREVAN (Realist English). First, they handed over part of the Holy Land to the Baku fascists, betraying the Armenians of...

All rights reserved.

© 2017-2025

  • About Us
  • Mission and Values
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

Follow Realist English

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Russia
  • Caucasus
  • Opinion
  • Interviews
  • Experts

Русский/English/العربية