Realist: news and analytics

Русский/English/العربية

  • News
  • Russia
  • Caucasus
  • Opinion
  • Interviews
  • Experts
No Result
View All Result
Realist: news and analytics
  • News
  • Russia
  • Caucasus
  • Opinion
  • Interviews
  • Experts
No Result
View All Result
Realist: news and analytics

Modi’s BJP and the restructuring of Indian capitalism: A historic shift in bourgeois leadership

Historian Vanessa Chishti argues that the BJP has achieved what Congress could not — consolidating big capital while sidelining rival factions.

   
May 27, 2025, 09:31
World
Modi’s BJP and the restructuring of Indian capitalism: A historic shift in bourgeois leadership

DELHI (Realist English). Under the leadership of Narendra Modi, India’s ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has not merely continued the neoliberal project—it has transformed the relationship between the Indian state and its capitalist classes. While critics often focus on the BJP’s authoritarianism and cronyism, historian Vanessa Chishti contends the real novelty lies elsewhere: in the regime’s successful consolidation of big capital and its ability to restructure India’s fractured bourgeois order.

In a sweeping analysis of India’s political economy, Chishti—who teaches history at O.P. Jindal Global University and researches the evolution of modern Kashmir—explores how the BJP has moved beyond the coalition politics that constrained its predecessors and redefined class relations through a combination of centralization, state patronage, and targeted economic reform.

“The BJP’s ability to push the interests of big capital—against the inertia of rival factions and the electoral power of rural classes—is unprecedented in post-independence India,” Chishti argues.

From fragmented capitalism to hegemonic alignment

India’s capitalist class has long been fragmented: comprising industrial giants, region-bound manufacturers, agrarian capitalists, and a vast sea of small-scale producers operating in the informal economy. Historically, no political party—not even the dominant Indian National Congress (INC)—succeeded in aligning these interests under one national project. The INC’s rule, held together by patronage and compromise, began to unravel in the 1960s as agrarian and regional capitalists defected.

What the BJP has accomplished since 2014—and solidified through its 2019 and 2024 electoral victories—is the subordination of small and agrarian capital to the imperatives of big capital, often at the cost of its own traditional voter base among traders and small manufacturers.

“The BJP has broken decisively from its roots as a party of small capital and refashioned itself as the primary political vehicle of India’s industrial bourgeoisie,” Chishti notes.

Big capital’s moment — and its limits

Backed by corporate media, financial conglomerates, and monopolists in infrastructure, energy, and telecom, the BJP has slashed welfare programs, enacted long-desired labor law reforms, and overseen an aggressive privatization campaign. It has written off billions in corporate bad debts and absorbed risk through state banks—what Chishti calls a system of “riskless capitalism.”

Yet this consolidation faces structural constraints.

India’s rural sector, agrarian elites, and informal economy—which accounts for 90–95% of livelihoods—remain politically potent. Despite attempts to reduce their leverage through tax reforms like the Goods and Services Tax (GST) and deregulation of agricultural markets, the BJP has faced pushback, most notably during the 2020–21 farmers’ protests, where it was forced to repeal a major set of agricultural laws.

“The BJP has streamlined the policy environment in favor of big capital, but the rural sector remains too large, too embedded in the electoral calculus to be ignored,” Chishti observes.

Centralization as a tool of class consolidation

A hallmark of the Modi era has been political and fiscal centralization, undermining India’s asymmetric federalism and curbing state governments’ ability to provide off-budget subsidies or circumvent central tax rules. The GST, for instance, limits subnational discretion over fiscal policy and consolidates capital accumulation pathways at the national level.

Yet, paradoxically, the decentralized nature of land regulation and the political autonomy of state governments—even in BJP-ruled states—continue to provide space for regional capitalists and agrarian elites to resist complete alignment with big industrial interests.

The Congress and the collapse of bourgeois compromise

By contrast, the Congress Party—once the default party of Indian capital—has lost its role as a broker between competing capitalist factions. The INC’s coalition-era governance (2004–2014) failed to implement reforms demanded by corporate India while alienating rural partners with its inability to rein in inflation and sustain populist transfers.

The tipping point came with the passage of the Land Acquisition Act (2013), which, under pressure from anti-displacement movements, curtailed the ability of corporations to cheaply seize land. For many industrialists, this marked the final rupture with Congress.

“Big capital’s desertion of the INC—and its strategic embrace of the BJP—completed a historic shift in Indian bourgeois leadership,” Chishti argues.

Patronage as policy: The enduring logic

Despite ideological differences, both the BJP and INC have governed through patronage. What distinguishes the BJP is its ability to discipline rival factions and restructure patronage to serve accumulation by large industrial firms. This has included redirecting subsidies, state procurement contracts, and public investment to sectors favored by the party’s corporate backers.

Even as public sector disinvestment slowed under Congress due to left-wing opposition, the BJP has accelerated it, often without parliamentary scrutiny.

“The Modi government has not abandoned patronage; it has simply rationalized and centralized it in ways that advantage the most powerful actors in Indian capitalism,” Chishti explains.

The unresolved contradiction

Despite its dominance, the BJP cannot escape the core contradiction of India’s political economy: the tension between capital accumulation and democratic legitimacy. Universal suffrage continues to empower classes that capitalist transformation threatens to displace—small farmers, informal workers, and petty producers.

“The contradiction between economic liberalization and mass democracy hasn’t disappeared,” Chishti warns. “It has only been managed more aggressively—through cultural nationalism, coercion, and centralization.”

What Vanessa Chishti’s analysis reveals is a deeper transformation of Indian capitalism under the BJP—not just in its policy direction, but in its class composition. The BJP has succeeded where Congress faltered: consolidating the interests of big capital into a coherent national agenda. But that consolidation remains partial, contested, and constrained by the very democratic structures that once gave India its developmental trajectory. The crisis of bourgeois leadership may be less visible—but it has not been resolved. Only restructured.

AsiaIndiaIndia’s Domestic PolicyNarendra Modi
Previous Post

Poland launches €1 billion expansion of EU’s only broad-gauge rail terminal to boost Ukraine trade and Asia cargo

Next Post

Putin hails ‘Russia – Land of Opportunity’ as a true social elevator as platform marks 7th anniversary

Related Posts

Japan calls China’s expanding military operations its ‘greatest strategic challenge’
World

Japan calls China’s expanding military operations its ‘greatest strategic challenge’

15 July, 2025
Taiwan’s military trains in metro stations and city streets as Han Kuang drills enter urban phase
World

Cameroon’s 92-year-old president Paul Biya announces bid for eighth term

15 July, 2025
Orban under pressure: Hungary’s ‘illiberal democracy’ faces a centre-right challenger
World

Orban under pressure: Hungary’s ‘illiberal democracy’ faces a centre-right challenger

14 July, 2025
Orban under pressure: Hungary’s ‘illiberal democracy’ faces a centre-right challenger
World

Iran slams Netanyahu over missile remarks, calls Israel’s war aims a failure

14 July, 2025
Trump’s 30% tariffs ignite EU backlash and threaten trade war escalation
World

China deepens strategic ties with Egypt amid Middle East tensions and global realignments

13 July, 2025
Trump’s 30% tariffs ignite EU backlash and threaten trade war escalation
World

Erdoğan hails ‘new page in history’ as Kurdish militants begin disarmament

13 July, 2025
Most Popular
Most Popular
Orban under pressure: Hungary’s ‘illiberal democracy’ faces a centre-right challenger

Iran slams Netanyahu over missile remarks, calls Israel’s war aims a failure

14 July, 2025

TEHRAN (Realist English). Iran’s Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi has sharply rebuked Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, declaring that Tel Aviv...

Gen X poised for major inheritance boom amid record baby boomer wealth transfers

Gen X poised for major inheritance boom amid record baby boomer wealth transfers

13 July, 2025

WASHINGTON (Realist English). Members of Generation X — those currently aged 45 to 60 — are expected to benefit from...

Trump’s 30% tariffs ignite EU backlash and threaten trade war escalation

Erdoğan hails ‘new page in history’ as Kurdish militants begin disarmament

13 July, 2025

ANKARA (Realist English). Turkey’s President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan declared the beginning of a new era as militants from the outlawed...

FBI launches criminal investigation into former CIA and FBI chiefs over 2016 Russia probe

FBI launches criminal investigation into former CIA and FBI chiefs over 2016 Russia probe

9 July, 2025

WASHINGTON (Realist English). The Federal Bureau of Investigation has opened criminal investigations into former CIA Director John Brennan and former...

Opinion

Roman Starovoit

Roman Starovoit and the collapse of a technocratic glossy dream

8 July, 2025

MOSCOW (Realist English). I can’t stop thinking about the story of Roman Starovoit. If you think about it, the former...

Bezos’s Venetian wedding: a manifesto of new feudalism

Bezos’s Venetian wedding: a manifesto of new feudalism

30 June, 2025

VENICE (Realist English). When Jeff Bezos rents half of Venice for a $50 million wedding, it is more than the...

Not Mossad’s strength — but Iran’s weakness

Not Mossad’s strength — but Iran’s weakness

16 June, 2025

TBILISI (Realist English). The recent targeted assassinations of senior IRGC commanders and high-ranking Iranian officers are not simply the triumph...

The Church belongs to Christ, not to politicians: The Armenian Apostolic Church becomes a casualty of Yerevan’s political agony

The Church belongs to Christ, not to politicians: The Armenian Apostolic Church becomes a casualty of Yerevan’s political agony

12 June, 2025

YEREVAN (Realist English). First, they handed over part of the Holy Land to the Baku fascists, betraying the Armenians of...

All rights reserved.

© 2017-2025

  • About Us
  • Mission and Values
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

Follow Realist English

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Russia
  • Caucasus
  • Opinion
  • Interviews
  • Experts

Русский/English/العربية